Methods, done simply

The two-list strategy, and what we know about it

The two-list strategy says: write down your top 25 goals, circle the 5 that matter most, and treat the other 20 as an avoid-at-all-costs list until the 5 are done. It is usually told as advice Warren Buffett gave his pilot, but that story is unverified: it reached the internet second-hand, and Buffett has reportedly said it was not his. The idea stands on its own, and research on goal shielding offers it some indirect support.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad

Last checked

On this page

The story, and how much of it is true

The version most people know comes from an article by James Clear, retelling a story his friend Scott Dinsmore had heard from Mike Flint, who Clear says was Warren Buffett’s personal pilot for ten years. As Clear tells it, Buffett asked Flint to:

  1. Write down his top 25 career goals.
  2. Circle the 5 most important.
  3. Treat the other 20 not as a second priority but as an “avoid-at-all-cost” list, getting no attention until the top 5 were done.

The twist, and the reason the story spread, is step 3. Flint planned to work on the other 20 “intermittently”; Buffett supposedly told him he had it wrong.

The attribution is unverified. The story reached the web second-hand: from Flint, to Dinsmore’s blog (which no longer loads), to Clear’s article and countless copies. Versions differ even on the pilot’s name. The writer August Birch reports that Alex Banayan, in his book The Third Door, describes asking Buffett about the method at a Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting, and that Buffett said it was not him. We have not been able to read Banayan’s account directly, and we found no place where Buffett himself tells the story. So the safest summary is: a memorable method, told about Buffett, that Buffett has reportedly disowned.

None of that makes the method bad. It means you should judge it by trying it, not by the name attached.

Try it this week on paper

The life-goals version takes an hour; the weekly version takes ten minutes. Clear himself suggests the shorter one works too.

  1. Write 15 to 25 things you want to get done this week, or this quarter if you prefer. Work and home, big and small.
  2. Circle three to five. Ask which ones you would be most glad to have finished on Friday. Stop at five.
  3. Copy the uncircled items onto a separate sheet and put it away, out of sight. That is your “not now” list.
  4. Work only on the circled items until they are done or you deliberately decide to change them. When an uncircled item tugs at you, notice it and leave it.
  5. On Friday, take out the second sheet. Cross out what no longer matters, and choose next week’s circles. A weekly review is a natural place for this.

Two practical cautions. Some uncircled items will be obligations, such as bills, appointments and other people’s deadlines; those still happen, because “avoid” is about goals you chose, not duties you owe. And if your circles are all urgent chores, you may be falling for urgency: research on the “mere urgency effect” found people pick tasks that only look urgent over more valuable ones.

What the evidence says, and where it is weak

No study tests the 25/5 method. Its appeal rests on the Buffett story, which is shaky, and on the logic of the steps.

Goal shielding offers indirect support. In six studies published in 2002, the psychologists Shah, Friedman and Kruglanski found that when people were committed to a focal goal, competing goals became less accessible in their minds, and this shielding helped them pursue and reach the focal goal. The two-list method tries to do deliberately what shielding does by itself: keep rivals from pulling attention. The researchers also found the effect was weaker for competing goals that helped the main one, which fits a common-sense reading of the method: keep the uncircled items that make the top five easier.

The weak spots. Writing off 20 goals can be too blunt for a life with many roles; a parent, a job and health all need some attention every week. Goals change, and a five-item list set in January may be wrong by March. And the method says nothing about the order of the five; for that, a short daily list such as the Ivy Lee method or most important tasks does the job. The Pareto principle makes the same bet from a different angle: a few items carry most of the value.

Where Dozen helps, and where it doesn’t

The circling is a paper job. Dozen helps with keeping the uncircled items out of the way without losing them. A to-do can be set to Someday, which puts it on hold without a date. Spaces holds your lists, projects, areas and tags. When Today holds more than your usual day, Lighten offers to move the few things that can wait, and nothing moves until you say so. Close the Year shows the year’s numbers and lets you keep or let go of what waited all year.

Where it does not help: Dozen has no goals feature and does not pick your top five. It has no shared lists for a team’s priorities. And Dozen is not out yet; two sheets of paper, one of them put in a drawer, are the whole method.

Questions and answers

Did Warren Buffett really invent the 25/5 rule?

There is no evidence he did. The story reached the web through a blogger who heard it from Buffett’s former pilot, not from Buffett, and the writer Alex Banayan reports that when he asked Buffett about it at a shareholder meeting, Buffett said it was not his. Treat the attribution as unverified.

Do I have to give up the other 20 goals forever?

No. The idea is to give them no attention until the top five are done or deliberately changed. Writing them on a someday list keeps them safe without letting them compete. Many people find a few of the 20 no longer matter when they look again months later.

Does this work for a weekly to-do list, not life goals?

Yes, in a smaller form. James Clear suggests the same steps for a shorter timeline, such as the things you want to get done this week. Write the week’s list, circle three to five, and leave the rest until those are done.

Sources

What this page says about Dozen was checked against the app on .

Last checked:

Get Dozen

Dozen is free to download. Dozen Pro, a monthly or yearly subscription, adds the Assistant.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad

Dozen: Tasks & Notes

Dozen is free to download. Dozen Pro, a monthly or yearly subscription, adds the Assistant.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad