Guilt, overwhelm and letting go

Your to-do list will never be finished. That is fine.

A to-do list that holds everything you might do will never be finished, because new things arrive faster than any day can clear them. That is how lists work, not a sign you are behind. Keep two lists: an inventory that is allowed to grow, and a list for today that holds only what an ordinary day can. Finish or move everything on today’s list each evening. The inventory never ends; your day can.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad

Last checked

On this page

Why the list never ends

Adding a task takes three seconds. Doing one takes ten minutes, or an afternoon, or a month. Every email, meeting, school letter and passing idea can add a line, and nothing removes lines except you. So a list that holds everything you might do grows faster than any person can shrink it. That is arithmetic, not a character flaw.

You are in good company. Writing in Harvard Business Review in 2018, the psychologist Art Markman observed that most people he knows have a to-do list so long that it is not clear there is an end to it. The list being endless is ordinary. What hurts is treating an endless list as a single job you are failing to finish.

Two lists: the inventory and the day

The way out is to stop asking one list to do two jobs.

  • The inventory is everything you might do: projects, errands, ideas, things you promised to look into. It is allowed to be long. It is allowed to grow. Its job is to hold things so your head does not have to.
  • The day is the handful of things you will actually try to do today. It is short on purpose. Its job is to end.

Most guilt about to-do lists comes from looking at the inventory and judging yourself as if it were the day. Nobody finishes an inventory. A shop does not feel bad that its stockroom is full.

Apple’s Reminders already works this way: its built-in Today smart list shows only what is due today, however long your other lists are. A paper notebook works too, with the long list on the left page and today on the right.

What an endless list costs, and what helps

The cost of a long list is not the list. It is the thinking about it at the wrong time. In a 2017 diary study, researchers followed 59 employees for 12 weeks. On weeks that ended with more unfinished tasks, people slept worse at the weekend, and the link ran through rumination: going over the unfinished work with bad feelings. Over the whole three months, people with more unfinished tasks overall had more trouble sleeping at weekends.

There is a well-tested way to quiet that loop. In experiments by E. J. Masicampo and Roy Baumeister, unfinished goals caused intrusive thoughts and got in the way of other work. When people wrote a specific plan for those goals, the interference went away, even though the goals were still unfinished. You cannot finish an endless list, but you can make sure every item that is bothering you has a plan or a home.

How to live with a list that never ends

  1. Split the list. Keep one place for everything and one short list for today. If you only have one list, start a second one now with no more than a few lines on it.
  2. Fill today from what you usually finish. Count how many things you really get done on an ordinary day and stop there. How many to-dos you can really do in a day goes through it.
  3. End the day, not the list. In the evening, give each unfinished item on today’s list a destination: tomorrow, a named day, or let it go. Five minutes is enough; the steps are in the end-of-day shutdown.
  4. Prune the inventory once a week. Delete what no longer matters. Move what you might do one day to a someday list that you read once a month and never feel guilty about. Pick a few things for the week ahead. The weekly review is a fuller version.
  5. Count what you finished. The length of the list tells you how much the world asks of you. What you ticked off tells you what you did. Only the second one is a measure of your day.

If the inventory has grown past the point where pruning helps, with hundreds of stale items you avoid opening, it may be easier to start again. To-do list bankruptcy explains how to do that without losing what matters.

The finish lines you can have

An endless list does not mean you never get to finish anything. It means you choose smaller finish lines. A day can end with every item done or decided. A project can end; a week can end with a short review; a year can end with a look back at what you carried and what you put down. Those are real endings, and they are enough.

The list will be there tomorrow, longer than today. That is what lists do. Your job is not to beat it. Your job is to pick what fits in the day, do some of it, decide about the rest, and stop.

Where Dozen helps, and where it doesn’t

In Dozen, the split between the inventory and the day looks like this. Spaces holds your lists, projects, areas and tags. Dozen opens on Today. A bar on Today shows what is done, what is planned and what your usual day holds, so you can see a heavy day before you are in it. Your usual day is the median number of to-dos you finished on your 14 most recent working days. At the end of the day, Close the Day walks through what is left in Today and lets you send each thing to tomorrow, to a day you pick, or let it go. And at the end of the year, Close the Year shows the year’s numbers and lets you keep or let go of what waited all year.

Where it does not help: Dozen is not out yet, and the two-list habit works on paper or in Reminders today. Dozen does not block time on a calendar, so if you plan your day hour by hour, a calendar app does that part better. And it cannot make the inventory shorter; only your weekly pruning does that.

Questions and answers

Why does my to-do list keep getting longer?

Because adding a task takes seconds and doing one takes minutes or hours. Every message, meeting and idea can add a line. A list that only grows is normal; the fix is to keep the day’s list separate and to prune the long list once a week.

Should I aim to empty my to-do list?

Aim to empty today’s list, not the whole inventory. A day’s list can end every evening. The long list of everything you might do is a store cupboard: useful to have, never meant to be empty.

How often should I clear out a long to-do list?

A short weekly look is enough for most people. Delete what no longer matters, move what can wait to a someday list, and pick a few things for the coming week.

Sources

What this page says about Dozen was checked against the app on .

Last checked:

Get Dozen

Dozen is free to download. Dozen Pro, a monthly or yearly subscription, adds the Assistant.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad

Dozen: Tasks & Notes

Dozen is free to download. Dozen Pro, a monthly or yearly subscription, adds the Assistant.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad